Hunter Baker: Protecting religious freedom

Editor's note: The following text is a transcript of a podcast story. To listen to the story, click on the arrow beneath the headline above.

NICK EICHER, HOST: Today is Tuesday, May 27th. Good morning! This is The World and Everything in It from listener-supported WORLD Radio. I’m Nick Eicher.

MARY REICHARD, HOST: And I’m Mary Reichard.

Religious liberty is a foundational American right. And President Trump recently formed the White House Religious Liberty Commission to help defend it.

But WORLD opinions contributor Hunter Baker says real protection will take more than a presidential panel.

HUNTER BAKER, COMMENTATOR: In the wake of the Supreme Court’s 2015 Obergefell decision that recognized same-sex marriage as a constitutional right, I finally saw a crisis take shape that I’d anticipated for nearly two decades. In 1999 I worked as a summer law associate with Prison Fellowship. We worked hard—trying to pass a bill that would have strengthened the 1993 Religious Freedom Restoration Act—or RFRA—a law that prevents the federal government from imposing substantial burdens on a person's religious exercise. Our bill failed.

We witnessed stout opposition from gay rights campaigners. I realized that the LGBTQ community identified religious liberty as a threat and would seek to confine free exercise of religion as much as possible.

When the Obergefell ruling came down, religious liberty and gay rights were on a collision course. The stage was set for the American left to use anti-discrimination legislation and regulations. Few Christians ever realized how serious the threat was and is.

Religious liberty has gone from being primarily a concern of religious minorities to a much broader kind of political issue. The continuing clash of religious and secular progressive sensibilities is powered by the sexual revolution. President Trump’s recent establishment of a White House Religious Liberty Commission is a sign of how much more prominent the issue has become.

The commission is specifically tasked with evaluating threats to religious liberty and seeking ways to enhance protections. Notably, an examination of the history of American religious liberty is part of the agenda. Historically speaking, it would make sense to emphasize the degree to which religious liberty is one of the most distinctive American values. Those who argue First Amendment religious liberty somehow skirts the law or operates as a “get out of jail free” card ignore the fact that free exercise is part of our most fundamental law, the U.S. Constitution.

The commission’s roster reveals some serious heavy hitters in the area of religious liberty. They all represent tremendous engagement with issues involving the free exercise of religion.

While it is true that the Supreme Court has been relatively friendly to religious liberty claims in recent years, the better course of action is to attempt to make changes in law to better support the constitutional right. As an example, the Religious Freedom Restoration Act was the primary reason Hobby Lobby survived the Obama administration’s HHS mandate. That forced employers to provide birth control and abortifacients in their insurance plans. Without the protection of RFRA, Hobby Lobby would have either been ruined by enormous fines or forced to sell.

The problem is that in the years shortly after RFRA’s passage, the coalition for religious liberty fell apart. A later attempt aimed at pressing for greater protection in the states. But that legislation ended up being greatly diluted into the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act and was of no help to claimants such as the Colorado baker Jack Phillips, who continues to be targeted in his state. Further, it is the case that recent legislation from the secular left has explicitly aimed to exclude or limit the operation of RFRA.

The White House Religious Liberty Commission will produce a report, which we can hope will be influential. But what is important is that this emphasis on religious liberty not be an isolated event of the kind that pops up as a public policy fad. Rather, religious liberty deserves sustained attention by American citizens and officials. The great Catholic political theorist John Courtney Murray helped lead his church toward the embrace of religious liberty in the middle of the 20th century. He effectively argued that the religion clauses of the constitution act as “articles of peace.” Contrary to secular progressive arguments that religious freedom somehow deforms democracy, Murray noted that honoring religious liberty is deeply practical as it helps people live together in a pluralistic society. Let’s hope that President Trump’s commission can remind Americans how important it is to honor faith rather than try to steamroll it into submission.

I’m Hunter Baker.

WORLD Radio transcripts are created on a rush deadline. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of WORLD Radio programming is the audio record.